| Project Legion de Lance Kawas 2.71 pts. | |
| The haunting of Pendle Hill de Richard John Taylor 2.75 pts. | |
| Jeepers Creepers 4. El Renacer de Timo Vuorensola 2.84 pts. | |
| 2025: La Purga Anual de Josh E. Williams 3.03 pts. | |
| Amityville Uprising de Thomas J. Churchill 3.09 pts. | |
| The Ghosts of Monday de Francesco Cinquemani 3.12 pts. | |
| Reign of Chaos de Rebecca Matthews 3.15 pts. | |
| Sharkula de Mark Polonia 3.16 pts. | |
| The Prototype de Marcelo Grion 3.25 pts. | |
| Conjuring: The Beyond de Calvin Morie McCarthy 3.27 pts. | |
| Galaxy Games de Ben Carland 3.34 pts. | |
| De Caza de K. Asher Levin 3.46 pts. | |
| Sadako DX de Hisashi Kimura 3.50 pts. | |
| The Legend of La Llorona de Patricia Harris Seeley 3.52 pts. | |
| Live Escape de Joe Lujan 3.55 pts. | |
| Jikirag de Jessica Moutray, Leigah Keewatin, Alexander J. Baxter 3.60 pts. | |
| #Float de Zac Locke 3.61 pts. | |
| Croc! de Paul W. Franklin 3.64 pts. | |
| The Long Dark Trail de Kevin Ignatius, Nick Psinakis 3.68 pts. | |
| The Huntress of Auschwitz de Richard John Taylor 3.68 pts. | |
| Jurassic Island de Dominic Ellis 3.68 pts. | |
| Monsters in the Closet de The Snygg Brothers 3.70 pts. | |
| Maneater de Justin Lee 3.70 pts. | |
| The Friendship Game de Scooter Corkle 3.70 pts. | |
| Sharkwater de Le-Van Kiet 3.71 pts. | |
| Fire Island de Myles Clohessy 3.80 pts. | |
| Beneath the Surface de Rebecca Matthews, Scott Jeffrey 3.84 pts. | |
| La Familia Monster de Rob Zombie 3.88 pts. | |
| The Overnight de Kevin Rhoades, Bobby Francavillo 3.89 pts. | |
| Wolf Mountain de David Lipper 3.96 pts. | |
| Deinfluencer de Jamie Bailey 3.98 pts. | |
| Titanic 666 de Nick Lyon 4.02 pts. | |
| Hunt Club de Elizabeth Blake-Thomas 4.03 pts. | |
| Evil Tapes de Alexander Henderson 4.04 pts. | |
| Mega Lightning de David Gregory 4.05 pts. | |
| Where the Scary Things Are de B. Harrison Smith 4.06 pts. | |
| The Winter Witch de Richard John Taylor 4.09 pts. | |
| The Bunker Game de Roberto Zazzara 4.13 pts. | |
| The Red Book Ritual de Dean W. Law, Logan Fields, Nicolás Onetti, Ariel Luque, Chris Beyrooty, Jiwon Moon, Daniel J. Phillips, Dean Puckett 4.13 pts. | |
| Bring it on 7: A por todas: Anima o Muere de Karen Lam 4.17 pts. | |
| Sin Eater de Carmelo Chimera 4.20 pts. | |
| Reed's Point de Dale Fabrigar 4.25 pts. | |
| The Unsettling de Harry Owens 4.29 pts. | |
| Zombies in the Antique Shop de Kimberly DiPersia, Alex R. Wagner 4.33 pts. | |
| The Harbinger de Will Klipstine 4.33 pts. | |
| The Mummy: Resurrection de Steve Lawson 4.33 pts. | |
| Bridge of the Doomed de Michael Su 4.34 pts. | |
| Amenaza en las Profundidades de Lee Thongkham 4.34 pts. | |
| After the Pandemic de Richard Lowry 4.35 pts. | |
| The day after Halloween de Chad Ostrom 4.36 pts. |